I don't have an issue with any of the sketches listed in Splitsider's "24 Best 'Mr. Show' Sketches", just the order (I don't really get why The Story of Everest is so revered) and some glaring omissions. Of what's listed there, Taint, Larry Kleist and Fairsley's are my favorites. But look at the comedy gold that was left off!
Three Times One Minus One
Civil War vs. Ren Faire vs Star Trek
East Coast Vs. West Coast Ventriloquists
Rap: The Musical
The Burgandy Loaf
Josh Fenderman (ok, only me and Avery will appreciate this)
Show Me Your Weenis
Good News (timely, with Exodus International closing shop)
...and the all time greatest Mr. Show sketch, Titannica.